Side by side
Three years on MES, 2023-07 → 2026-07. Same signal set — the spread in the numbers is exit management and sizing, nothing else.
| method | exit | sizing | 3-yr net | PF | win | max DD | trades |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 Master TV-verified | M2 · half @ +1R, 15m-swing trail | fixed $200–250 / trade | +$16,294 | 1.72 | 59.1% | −$1,723 | 225 |
| P1 Master Flex | M2 · half @ +1R, 15m-swing trail | flexR · 0.10 × cushion (std) | +$23,446 | 1.59 | 60.0% | −$4,475 | 220 |
| P1 Fast entries TV-verified | M1be · full @ +2R, BE @ +1R | fixed $800 / trade · 20-micro cap | +$29,674 | 1.52 | 34.5% | −$5,752 | 225 |
| P1 Fast Flex | M1be · full @ +2R, BE @ +1R | flexR · 0.10 × cushion (std) | +$9,184 | 1.43 | 34.5% | −$3,536 | 220 |
Max DD is end-of-day for Master/Fast, book drawdown for the flex overlays. Win rates differ by exit style, not signal quality — M1be converts fewer trades but wins 2R when it does.
Pick by the job
- Passing the TPT 25K eval, or trading funded: P1 Master. $200/trade never failed a start in three years of simulated eval starts; step to $250 after +$750 banked.
- Passing a PRO-style eval (no consistency rule) quickly: P1 Fast — 96% of 2026 start days passed within 30 trading days in the stored eval sims (68% across all three years).
- Growing a funded account from a thin cushion: the Flex overlays — size follows the cushion, so a losing streak can’t breach the floor the way fixed-$ risk can.
- Automation: P1 Fast Flex is the config wired into the TradingView → PickMyTrade → Tradovate pipeline.
The methods
P1 Master TV-verified
The champion. Half off at +1R, trail the rest — built for the TPT 25K eval and funded trading.
→ /p1-master-flex/P1 Master Flex
P1 Master trades with flexible-R sizing: risk a fixed fraction of the cushion above the trailing drawdown floor.
→ /p1-fast/P1 Fast entries TV-verified
Same entries, one fixed +2R target, breakeven at +1R — tuned to pass PRO-style evals fast.
→ /p1-fast-flex/P1 Fast Flex
P1 Fast trades with flexible-R sizing — the automated LucidPro-style eval configuration.
→